Case Study: Guy Turcotte

CASE STUDY by Nadia P. Chouinard On February 20th 2009, cat Turcotte, a 39 year-old cardiologist at the St. Jérômes Hotel Dieu Hospital, stabbed his deuce children to death, Olivier, 5, and Anne-Sophie, 3, in a house Turcotte had rented in Piedmont, 65 kilometers northwest of Montreal. He then tried investting suicide, unsuccess full moony. afterward an intense 10-week trial, the finding of fact was decided: Guy Turcotte is non criminally responsible for the double-murder by cause of custodytal disorder. Thus, sooner of serving time in jail, he will be staying in the Philippe Pinel Psychiatric constitute until he is judged safe to be released. As described in the Montreal Gazette, half(a) of the spectators in the lawcourt let out a sigh of relief and half sat in stupefy shock (Montgomery, Verdict). Obviously, this stopping point did non please everybody, and many lesson dilemmas arose. For instance, is it forgivable for mentally disabled to commit murder ? How do we determine the mental condition of a criminal? If an one-on-one doesnt know what he is doing is wrong, does it sterilise it undecomposed? many people and organizations are directly mixed in this good issue. First, the family of Guy Turcotte, more specifically, Isabelle Gaston, is directly implicated in the situation.

As the mother of the children, her quality is to make real that nothing wish this happens again: No adult has the right to determine the sustenance and death of chil-dren (Montgomery, Gaston). Gaston is extremely disappointed in the verdict. Nonetheless, she is aware she has to be given on because , like she overlap to the Gazette, [she] wo! uldnt have been satisfied because [she]ll never get [her] children back (Montgomery, Verdict). Second, the arbiter organization of Quebec is involved because it is their role to make the fair decision of this delicate situation. More precisely, it was the jury of seven women and four men who were responsible for the final verdict. The administrative Tribunal of Quebec composed of...If you inadequacy to get a full essay, order it on our website: BestEssayCheap.com

If you want to get a full essay, visit our page: cheap essay